
- E = sigma Te^4 - sigma Ta^4, (photon particle model: difference of two-way gross flows)
- E = sigma (Te^4 - Ta^4) ~ 4 sigma Te^3 (Te - Ta), (wave model: net one-way flow)
Leibniz dreamed of machines that could calculate and reason. Three hundred and fifty years later, mathematics has created AI, a machine that can both calculate and reason—and thereby create new mathematics. Mathematics has become a tool for its own development. What is the role of human reasoning?

When controversies arise, there will be no more need of disputation between two philosophers than between two accountants. For it will suffice to take their pens in their hands, to sit down to their counting tables, and to say to each other: Let us calculate. Leibniz, The Art of Discovery (1685)
For when propositions are denied, there is an end
of them, but if they bee allowed, it requireth a
new worke. The Essais of Sr. Francis Bacon, London, 1612
The further a society drifts from the truth, the more it will hate those who speak it. George Orwell
Nothing is created by coincidence, rather there is reason and necessity for everything. Leukippus, 5th Century BC.
De Omnibus Dubitandum
Science advances one funeral at a time.
Max Planck
I think I get your point Claes. But wouldn't it be useful to explain to the "babies" that version 1 doesn't lead to a greenhouse effect. Why shoot a fly with bazzoka?
SvaraRaderaYou are right, but what do you when there is no communication, when there is no wave equation, when there are only soul-less particles emptied into a void?
SvaraRaderaBut Claes, why do you have to invent such mystical communication theories when he reality is so simple. If the atmosphere is at the same temterature as the earth surface and is supposed to be a black body, like the earth surface, there is of course no net radiation in any direction. But you can be sure that there is a lot af electromagnetic waves, carrying energy, exchanged between the two black bodies, acc to the SB two body law.
SvaraRaderaI hope you don`t deny this, for if so, there is no meaning of having a discussion with you.
And if you gradually increases one of the temperatures, I hope you easily understand that the other body not suddenly stops emitting at the same level as before. The body with increased temperature of course increases the emitted energy compared to the earlier state. I really hope you agree with me in this very simple case.
But this doesn`t mean that there must be a green house effect. The "back radiation" from the atmosphere is of course reradiated back to the atmosphere, starting the same procedure over again, but some energy is every time passing through the atmosphere into space, and finally all the original energy is reaching space. Perhaps some part of it is absorbed in the atmosphere heating it. And this heated atmosphere makes the earth loose a little less energy acc to the SB two body law, and thus the earth is heated a little, but perhaps not very much. So I think you can stop the discussion about babies and so on. It doesn`t add anything to the greenhouse debate.
Who formulated and proved the two-body SB law you refer to?
SvaraRaderaSee also new blog post.
SvaraRaderaIf there is only one body, the radiated energy is given by the SB law. The empty space is at 0´K. If this temp instead was at T, the same as the body, the net energy radiated would be zero. So there has to be some mathematical expression describing this, and the SB two body law, your eq 1, is the best eq found to make this job. And I think it is in accordance with experiments.
SvaraRaderaThe equation can be interpreted in different ways, and this is what we are discussing. You did not answer my question about who proved 1.
SvaraRaderahe "back radiation" from the atmosphere is of course reradiated back to the atmosphere, starting the same procedure over again,
SvaraRadera