Visar inlägg med etikett NADA. Visa alla inlägg
Visar inlägg med etikett NADA. Visa alla inlägg

tisdag 29 oktober 2013

NADAs Begravning Firas Stort på KTH

KTH inbjuder till firande av NADAs 50-årsdag enligt nedanstående affisch. Vad som inte omnämns i inbjudan är att NADA är nedlagt och inte längre finns med oss: Att det handlar om en begravning av något dött och inte ett födelsdagsfirande av något levande. Att Numerisk Analys (NA) inte längre är en egen institution utan har inlemmats i Matematik och nu går samma öde till mötes som Numerisk Analys vid Chalmers, som inte längre är ett undervisningsämne och därmed förlorat sin uppgift. Så motsvarar då NADA till slut sin betydelse på portugisiska, nämligen "ingenting", "nothing".

Att Numerisk Analys har gått i graven beror inte på att ämnet saknar aktualitet, hela vårt IT-samhälle bygger ju på Numerisk Analys i olika former, utan på att NADA stelnat i den form och med det innehåll NADA hade under pionjärtiden för 50 år sedan. Så kan framgång byggd på initiell kompetens och efterfrågan (jfr med Nokia) utvecklas till en tvångströja som kväver nytänkande och utveckling och därmed bäddar för undergång.  I inbjudan omskrivs detta som "lite nostalgi" och firandet fokuseras på "musik och sång" och "Demonstration av Historisk Klenod", kanske bysten av Germund Dahlquist, grundaren av NADA (en mycket sympatisk person som både kunde räkna och spela piano):




Guldjubiléum



Informationsbehandling 1963 Numerisk Analys - Datalogi
Tid: Ti 2013-12-17 kl 13.30
Plats: E1 och Sing-Sing
För 50 år sedan installerades på KTH den första professorn i Informationsbehandling, särskilt Numerisk Analys, och institutionen grundades. Tisdag 17 december blir det tillfälle för oss på CSC och NA att fira.

Preliminärt program från kl. 13.30 (Obs!) i sal E1:

• Presentationer, framtidsorienterade och blandade med lite nostalgi av bland andra
Anna-Karin Tornberg, Anders Flodström, Jan Gulliksen, Ingrid Melinder, Bertil Gustafsson & Björn Engquist, Haibo Li & Kia Höök & Ylva Fernaeus, Patrik Fältström & Anders Hillbo, Johan Hoffman, Svante Littmarck, Leo Giertz, Jin Moen & Marie Björkman, Yngve Sundblad & Peter Graham
• Jubileumspublikationer
• Demonstration av historisk klenod
• Avslutande middag med musik och sång
c:a kl.18.30 i Sing-Sing

Inbjudan:

Alla på CSC och NA är inbjudna.
Övriga deltagare efter särskild inbjudan.

Anmälan:

till Ann-Britt Isaksson Öhman senast den 29 november. (ange om du är med också på middagen)
Festkommittén
Lennart Edsberg, Ingrid Melinder, Yngve Sundblad





torsdag 10 februari 2011

KTH Dumps Simulation Technology vs Ipad Apps


The new Bachelor program in Simulation Technology (ST) at KTH planned to start in the Fall this year, has been stopped by the Department of Numerical Analysis (NADA) within the School of Computer Science and Communication, the same department which proposed and dragged the program through all the levels of KTH to applause and acceptance at the top level.

In the fight for students, which is getting increasingly tough, this is like winning the first prize
in an architecture competition of a new opera, but then simply throwing the winning drawings into the waste basket and walking away without making the dream of the beautiful building come true, leaving this to others, in this case to Malmö College.

At the same time SVT reports about the booming market of Ipad Apps as another name of Simulation Technology, and the alarming lack of education and competence in Sweden in this
area. Ipad Apps are to be created at Malmö College but not at KTH. Of course a university like KTH does not play in the same league as a little college. After all Apps are something made by the people for the people, nothing for royalties.

Why NADA decided to throw its baby ST into the waste basket? See previous posts on NADA
and KTH-gate.

The students of Numerical Methods II, where the e-version of BodyandSoul (eBS) has been tested as a basis of ST, have been helpful in stopping ST by throwing eBS into the waste basket. Why? Because Ipad Apps/ST/eBS is incompatible with the conservative royal education at KTH
and its conservative royal students, where ST students evidently have no place.

But even in the Royal Kingdom of Sweden the support of royals is fading.


lördag 5 februari 2011

Nothing Instead of Something 2

The School of Computer Science and Communication (CSC) at KTH has now decided to stop the new Bachelors program in Simulation Technology (ST) based on BodyandSoul (BS) geared to start in the Fall 2011 with everything in place. Instead a new ST program without a trace of BS is announced to start in the Fall 2012.

The decision to stop ST/BS was taken by a forceful intervention by my collegue Björn Engquist, U of Texas, who does not like BS. The result is that the new ST program will have to be developed from scratch and the substantial investment in ST/BS at CSC will be dumped. Of course this does not matter since the inflow of tax money is stable and tax payers have no insight.

Oh, how it can be that a prof at U of Texas can stop a program which KTH has decided to start?
Why not ask Björn himself or the Dean of CSC Jan Gulliksen.

Oh, why Björn does not like BS? Again ask him.

BS offers a reformed mathematics education for the IT-age: IT-mathematics. BS is thus basically synonymous with ST = IT-mathematics. ST based on standard pre-IT-age mathematics, would not make sense. ST based on IT-mathematics without BS, would require reinvention of BS, which does not make sense either.

But there is a lot in academics which does not make sense.

lördag 22 januari 2011

Why Nothing Rather Than Something?

Leibniz as a classic enlightened asked:
  • Why is there Something rather than Nothing?
  • Why is there Nothing rather than Something?
Let me illustrate with an example from my own experience with the department of Numerical Analysis NADA at KTH:
  • NADA in Portuguese means Nothing. So NADA = Nothing.
The story is told in Simulation Technology, BodyandSoul and NADA, and in short tells that rather than using anything connected to the educational program BodyandSoul, the leadership of NADA in the name of Björn Engquist chooses extinction: The new Bachelor program in Simulation Technology ST which is to start in the Fall at NADA according the decision of KTH, which would have saved NADA from disintegration into Nothingness, will not be allowed to start. KTH says Yes!, but NADA says No! The Soul say Yes! but (a part of) the Body says No!

Why? Because ST is connected to BodyandSoul = Something.

So we see that NADA prefers Nothing before Something. This is of course fully logical because we live in a postmodern time where values of enlightenement are no longer important.

Some quotes by Baudrillard:
  • The great person is ahead of their time, the smart make something out of it, and the blockhead, sets themselves against it.
  • If everything is perfect, language is useless. This is true for animals. If animals don't speak, it's because everything's perfect for them. If one day they start to speak, it will be because the world has lost a certain sort of perfection.
  • Like dreams, statistics are a form of wish fulfillment.
  • Fiction is not imagination. It is what anticipates imagination by giving it the form of reality. This is quite opposite to our own natural tendency which is to anticipate reality by imagining it, or to flee from it by idealizing it. That is why we shall never inhabit true fiction; we are condemned to the imaginary and nostalgia for the future.
PS January 31: I had a one-minute talk with the appointed leader of NADA Anna-Karin Thornberg, in the absence of NADA's spiritual leader Björn Engquist (former advisor of AK), during which Anna-Karin frankly informed me that nothing by my hand and mind could ever be used at NADA, as long as Björn Engquist was in charge. A clear message that Nothing is preferred before Something, if that Something is connected to my name. Academics at its best.

torsdag 20 januari 2011

Censorship and Deletion of BodyandSoul

To
The School of Engineering Sciences (SCI) KTH
The School of Computer Science and Communication (CSC) KTH

Concerning Censorship and Deletion of BodyandSoul: Mathematical Simulation Technology (MST)

I have made my unpublished ebook MST available for use in the 2nd quarter course Numerical Methods II, for the purpose of testing the material for possible use in the new Bachelor
program in Simulation Technology.

This letter is to state that as the test period now ends with the course, end of January for most of the students and mid March for some, any downloaded pdf-file of MST should be deleted so that no further use of the material is possible without my consent (including excerpts made). MST should thus be viewed as non-existing when the courses are finished.

The deletion is motivated by a planned commercialization of MST, and is also in full accordance with the censorship of MST by SCI during the course.

I thus ask SCI and CSC to inform teachers and students about these conditions, in particular on the course home page, and I want to get a confirmation that my message has been received and understood.

Upon new request MST can be made available in a new agreement with me concerning conditions.

Sincerely

Claes Johnson

onsdag 12 januari 2011

Öppet Brev till NA-gruppen om ST: Ja eller Nej?

Till NA-Gruppen KTH

NA står inför beslut att starta det nya kandidatprogrammet i SimuleringsTeknik (ST) till hösten enligt plan, eller att lägga ner ST redan innan det startat.

Beslutet är avgörande för NAs framtid och det är nödvändigt att frågan öppet diskuteras ingående och att alla får tillfälle att uttrycka sin åsikt, vilket Anna-Karin som avdelningsföreståndare säger sig vara mån om.

Som ett led i denna beslutsprocess vill jag att alla tar ställning till följande alternativ, och snarast meddelar sin preferens till Anna-Karin för sammanställning och allmänt delgivande:
  1. Starta ST enligt plan på en bas av BodyandSoul (BS) Mathematical Simulation Technology, med alla möjligheter till alternativt material enligt inblandade lärares input. Regi: Johan och Johan.
  2. Lägg ner ST.
  3. Starta ST på en bas av ??. Regi: ?? och ??
Vad gäller BS så är alla varianter möjliga. Tex kan man plocka ut en hård kärna och lägga annat
i bakgrunden. Man kan byta namn och kalla det tex KraftWerk, som var Mårten Levenstams namn på prototypen till vårt Femlab senare FEniCS. Man kan lägga till godtyckligt antal standardböcker i Calculus, osv. Det viktigaste är principen om en syntes av matematik-beräkning-tillämpning och att denna princip får ett genomtänkt och genomarbetat uttryck. BodyandSoul kan reserveras för Kinas miljoner studenter som inte har några förutfattade meningar om vad Body and Soul är för nåt.

Tänk till och skicka Ditt svar till Anna-Karin snarast. Om Du har ett fjärde alternativ, så ange det. Bakgrundsmaterial finns på min blogg.

Vänliga hälsningar

Claes

PS Jag har frågat Germund på plan 4 och jag tycker mig ha uppfattat att han röstar för 1. med motivering
  1. Realistiskt. Mycket bra för alla.
  2. Realistiskt. Mycket dåligt för alla.
  3. Orealistiskt ??
Germund fattade en gång det avgörande beslutet att inte låta NA ätas upp av matematik, vilket givit NA en plats på KTH och i världen. Om man tvekar kanske man kan tänka efter vad Germund skulle ha sagt, eller säger. Kanske han skulle sagt att 1. inte är korkat, medan 2. är korkat, och att numeriker inte är så korkade som matematiker gärna vill få världen att tro. DS

BS Mathematical Simulation Technology kan laddas ner från min hemsida. Delar av BS testas nu i kursen Numerical Methods II.

måndag 10 januari 2011

Simulation Technology, BodyandSoul and NADA 2


Tomorrow the committee for education GRU at CSC will decide to subject the Bachelor program in Simulation Technology (ST) at KTH based on BodyandSoul (BS), to an emergency stop, or to let it start in the Fall according to plan.

However, the decision, of vital importance for the survival of Numerical Analysis at KTH (also named NADA = Nothing), has already been taken, and the decision is: STOP! NADA ST/BS!

How do I know? Because I am not invited to the meeting and I am the author of BS: If ST/BS was to start according to plan, an agreement with me to supply BS would be necessary, and no such agreement has been signed. Not even a preliminary discussion about such an agreement has taken place. NADA.

No evaluation of the performance of BS in the test course Numerical Analysis II, has been made, and would not matter anyway: Even if BS was found to be remarkably successful, which is likely, would the emergency stop of ST/BS be prevented, because the decision has already been made: STOP ST/BS. NADA ST/ST. At any price, by all means, as displayed in KTH-gate.

This means that my work to develop a new version of BS for ST, in agreement with NA, has lacked purpose all along, simply a funny joke to keep me busy with something meaningless.

But is it so funny to start the deconstruction of NA at KTH into the same annihilation as NA at Chalmers, according to a dictate by the school of (pure) mathematics? Into NADA. Honestly speaking?

PS The GRU meeting is postponed and so the decision to stop or let go.
Applications for ST are to be made before April 15 and the ST brochure (page 9 and 87) is out for eager students to view and dream about. Every delay of the emergency stop will increase the frustration of the students finding that their dream was just a dream...

PS Jan 12: The NA group is wrestling in agony over having to reject ST because it builds on BS and there are some people who don't like BS, while owning the ST program would bring so many advantages to so many people. Rejecting ST will bring NA into free fall, and apparently the forces (they have no faces and names) are so strong that annihilation is chosen before a bit of BS. If anything, it shows the strength of BS. But it is a sad story, for many including those who destroy.

PS Jan 20: It appears that now the mission is complete: ST/BS resolutely stopped by the leadership of NADA, behind closed doors without any open discussion. The same as if parents would stop their childs in their ambitions to do something constructive with their lives, just because the parents are envious and do not want to see their children having a better life than
they were able to.

The stop was effectuated by the virtual leader of NADA Björn Engquist during one of his rare one day real time visits to his department. Efficient leadership.

lördag 8 januari 2011

Simulation Technology, BodyandSoul and NA

Next week the Numerical Analysis group (NA) within the School of Computer Science and Communication at KTH (CSC), will decide to run the Bachelor program in Simulation Technology (ST) planned to start in the Fall 20111, or to make an emergency stop, as if ST
was one of the nuclear reactors in Sweden shut down this winther because insufficient maintenance over long time is threatening safety.

The reason for CSC to stop ST is that ST is based on the BodyandSoul (BS) mathematics reform program, and the School of Engineering Sciences (SCI) including Mathematics, Mechanics and Physics, is objecting to ST/BS.

Why is then SCI seeking to stop ST/BS? Because ST/BS is based on a modern synthesis of mathematics and computation threatening to replace traditional programs in mathematics, mechanics and physics forming the basis of SCI. In the fierce competition between schools, SCI thus will lose students and resources to CSC, unless ST is stopped.

In the business world SCI represents a big company with traditional technology, which is challenged by a small innovative company with new technology. In business this common situtation is usually handled by the big company buying the small innovative company, thereby eliminating both the threat and getting access to the new technology. The alternative of seeking to stop the new technology by e.g. a media campaign is seldom used, because it is well understood that it does not work. Stupidity in business leads to ruin. What about in academics then?

Well, academics is becoming more and more businesslike, and so the same rules should apply:
And yes, SCI has been trying to buy out NA from CSC for a long time and the deal may be closed any day.

What could then be a good strategy for NA facing a merge into SCI and mathematics? To give up the new ST/BS technology because of SCI says so? No, that would be very stupid. A small company without new technology will simply by eaten by the big traditional company and thus perish. Example: At Chalmers a traditional NA was merged with traditional mathematical sciences and accordingly perished along with traditional courses in numerical analysis.

But a small company with new technology can get a golden position in a big company. NA with ST/BS can get a strong position in the coming merge with SCI.

What do you think NA will do? Give up ST/BS? Not give up ST/BS? The decision will be taken next week and will be reported here. The bets are high.

What about ST without BS then? Would this be accepted by SCI? No, because ST is based on the forming principle of BS of a synthesis of math-computation-application, which is the red flag to SCI. Even if resources to develop a new BS-like program from scratch were available (they are not), any new BS-like program would meet the same resistance from SCI, as long as it has not been incorporated into a core product of SCI with sign reversed.