måndag 19 december 2022

A Dissenting Nobel Laureate in Physics

Gerhard 't Hooft received the 1999 Nobel Prize in Physics for 

  • elucidating the quantum structure of electroweak interactions in physics.

On Wikipedia he is presented as a Quantum Mechanics QM theory dissident:
  • 't Hooft has "deviating views on the physical interpretation of quantum theory".
  • He believes that there could be a deterministic explanation underlying quantum mechanics.
  • Using a speculative model he has argued that such a theory could avoid the usual Bell inequality arguments that would disallow such a local hidden-variable theory.
  •  In 2016 he published a book length exposition of his ideas which, according to 't Hooft, has encountered mixed reactions.
Here we can listen to what how Gerhard explains his position to a general audience: 


with the following key confessions:
  • QM is first of all a theory which is correct.
  • I am not going to put any doubt to the fundamental correct nature of QM.
  • The entire world is controlled by QM.
  • But a question was not answered properly: What is reality?
  • What is a particle, a field?
  • Bohr framed an agreement to not ask such questions.
  • I disagree, I am asking these questions.
  • Many worlds and pilot waves theories cannot be right.
  • QM sounds crazy, QM sounds wrong, but it works.
  • There should be a real world.
  • This is a dangerous thing to say.
  • I you say so you place yourself outside the discussion area. 
  • I am convinced we will get the truth about what QM really means, but it may take a long time...
So Gerhard says that QM is correct but at the same time that it cannot be correct. There must be something better yet to discover...

I have suggested Gerhard to take a look at RealQM and will report if I get a reaction. 



2 kommentarer:

  1. Do you think there is a parallel between CI and Bayesian logic, which is commonly treated as a more subjective thing than frequentist statistics?

    SvaraRadera
  2. I do not think that statistics is useful to describe atoms and molecules since these are stable deterministic building blocks.

    SvaraRadera