torsdag 11 april 2024

Is Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation Measurable?

Temperature fluctuations of CMB measured by COBE satellite. 


Pierre-Marie Robitaille leading the development of the 8 Tesla Ultra High Field human MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) scanner, used his deep knowledge of electromagnetic resonance to question the measurement of the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMB) by NASA's COBE satellite, awarded the Nobel Prize in 2008. 

This was not well received by the physics community and Robitaille was effectively cancelled academically (as far as I understand), but his very informative youtube channel Sky Scholar (with 50k subscribers and 145 videos) has survived. Take a look and compare with previous post on Man Made Universality of Black Body Radiation.

CMB is supposed to be the "cooled remnant of the first light that could ever travel freely throughout the Universe" at the very low temperature of 2.726 K above ultimate 0 K. Very cold indeed. More precisely, it is claimed that measured CMB spectrum is very close to a blackbody spectrum at 2.726 K. 

In previous posts I have posed the question if the spectrometer involved in measuring CMB is effectively measuring temperature or radiative flux, with the answer that temperature can be measured at distance by radiative equilibrium in the same way a thermometer in contact measures temperature and not heat flux by establishing radiative equilibrium. This is supported by the fact that it is a measured temperature of 2.726 K, which is the main characteristic of the postulated CMB, not its unknown radiative heat emission as a (small) possible contribution to global warming. Recalling previous posts and Robitaille, we know that the blackbody spectrum is a fiction only met by graphite and so one may ask why CMB could behave the same. 

In the view presented on Computational Blackbody Radiation the temperature measurement by NASA's COBE satellite as main evidence of the existence of CMB, is based on resonance between apparatus and cosmic background, which has to be singled out from all other resonances. Robitaille here presents the Oceans of the Earth as a possible source overwhelming CMB, thus questioning the existence of CMB.  

When your brain registers a sound arising from resonance between a sound source and eardrum, the direction to the source can be decided because you have two ears, but the distance to the source and so the origin of the sound is more difficult to determine in the presence of other possibly stronger sources.  Robitaille questions the possibility to single out CMB from the radiation from the Oceans.  Do you?

Inga kommentarer:

Skicka en kommentar