Visar inlägg med etikett Leibniz World of Math. Visa alla inlägg
Visar inlägg med etikett Leibniz World of Math. Visa alla inlägg

tisdag 10 november 2026

AI Calls for the Reeducation of Mathematics Teachers — But Is It Possible?

AI is fundamentally changing mathematics education. When AI can explain mathematical concepts, solve equations, prove theorems and construct computational models, the traditional role of the mathematics teacher as a provider of mathematical knowledge and techniques is rapidly losing its justification.

What remains for the mathematics teacher?

A new role is emerging: to guide students in mathematical investigations, identify meaningful problems, connect mathematics with the sciences, critically examine results and distinguish mathematical understanding from mere mathematical production.

The teacher of yesterday teaches students mathematics. The teacher of tomorrow does mathematics together with students.

Can teachers educated for the old role be reeducated?

But there is a fundamental difficulty: Can mathematics teachers educated for the old role be reeducated for the new one?

A university mathematics professor is the product of perhaps twenty or thirty years of education and research within a system emphasizing specialized knowledge, analytical techniques and the proof of theorems. Professional identity, academic prestige and career advancement are built upon these achievements.

AI now challenges the very foundations of this system.

A professor who has spent a lifetime mastering a particular mathematical technique may discover that AI can perform it in seconds. A first-year student equipped with AI may explore mathematics far beyond the professor's specialization.

The necessary reeducation is thus not simply a matter of learning to use AI. It requires a fundamentally different conception of mathematics and mathematics education.

The teacher must learn to move across mathematical disciplines, integrate computation with analytical reasoning, engage with scientific problems and participate in investigations without knowing the answers in advance.

Consider a professor of differential equations who has spent a career proving existence theorems but has never computed a solution of the Navier–Stokes equations. Can this professor be transformed into a teacher who guides students in constructing their own fluid solvers with AI and investigating the emergence of turbulence?

Possibly. But it requires more than acquiring new skills. It requires questioning the values and priorities that have shaped an entire professional life.

Who will organize the reeducation?

And who will organize this reeducation? The very mathematics departments whose culture and traditions are being challenged by AI?

There is a real risk that the response will be to defend the old system: restrict AI, insist on traditional examinations and continue teaching mathematical techniques whose practical importance is rapidly diminishing.

The alternative is to embrace AI as an opportunity to reunite mathematics, computation and the sciences, and to transform the classroom into a laboratory of mathematical discovery.

The reeducation of teachers must itself take the form of the new education: teachers must undertake AI-assisted mathematical investigations, explore unfamiliar territory and experience the intellectual freedom now available to their students.

Some teachers will welcome this transformation. Others may find it difficult or even impossible. Universities may have to educate and recruit an entirely new kind of mathematics teacher.

The decisive question

The decisive question for mathematics education after AI may not be whether students can learn mathematics in a new way. It may be whether mathematics teachers can.

And if they cannot, will mathematics education have to wait for a new generation of teachers — or will students simply move ahead without them? 

måndag 12 oktober 2026

How to be Master not Slave of LLM: Leibniz World of Math

Large-Language Models as a Cognitive Virus by Ricard Solé, Giulio Ruffini, Francesca Castaldo, Marco Tuccio, Luis F. Seoane, Manlio de Domenico, Santiago F. Elena, David C. Krakauer, Michael Levin:

  • There is a high risk of a run-away effect toward persistent dependence, with abrupt losses in cognitive competence. 
  • The same framework, however, identifies conditions for cognitive immunization, based on reducing transmission and facilitating reversibility. 
  • Our results highlight how LLM adoption may involve nonlinear collective transitions with important consequences for cognitive autonomy.
In other words, it remains to train cognitive capacities to not become a slave under LLM but the master of  LLM by keeping cognitive autonomy. What to do? Can school help? Mom and Dad? University? Life?
Physical training? 

Let us go back to Leibniz who formed the first vision of automated thinking and ask what advice he can give when 350 years later his vision has become true: The key to cognitive autonomy is 

Do not hesitate to take the first step to autonomy and mastery. 

torsdag 23 mars 2023

A Revolution in Physics Education

In a recent article in American Journal of Physics, William Flannery asks 

The article directly connects to the reform program for math/science education I have been working on since the 1980s as a synthesis of mathematical analysis, computation and application, with the following main insights:
  • The computer revolution in physics education will have two striking effects, both of which will happen overnight: differential equations will be taught in introductory physics, and the number and types of physical systems that can be analyzed will explode.
  • This will require rewriting the courses in classical physics, introductory to advanced.
I am happy to announce that such new course material is already available in the form of 
Read the article and compare with my reform program.

lördag 11 mars 2023

Why Is Quantum Mechanics Made So Crazy, Strange and Weird?



All leading physicists tell us that quantum mechanics as the physics of the microscopic world of atom physics, is crazy, strange and weird:

  • Quantum mechanics is weird. I don't understand it. Just live with it. You don't have to understand the nature of things in order to build cool devices. (Seth Lloyd)
  • I think I can safely say that nobody understands quantum mechanics. (Richard Feynman)
  • We are all agreed that your theory is crazy. The question which divides us is whether it is crazy enough to have a chance of being correct. My own feeling is that it is not crazy enough. (Niels Bohr)
  • Not only is the Universe stranger than we think, it is stranger than we can think. (Werner Heisenberg)
  • ....
Ok, so quantum mechanics is weird, but does it say that also Nature as what exists, is weird? Quantum mechanics is theory about the microscopic world constructed by physicists and if it is weird, it is because it is so constructed. 

On the other hand Nature as what exists cannot be weird, because things that are weird cannot exist over time. Anything weird will quickly collapse. Now the microscopic world of protons and electrons serves as the foundation of Nature and it is inconceivable that the very foundation what exists is weird. It is possible that there are macroscopic phenomena which can be described as weird as an Earth quake or car crash, but they are short-lived. It seems protons do not ever decay and so are remarkably long-lived and so cannot be truly weird. 

Ok, so real atom physics as the foundation of Nature cannot be truly weird. Only a theory about atom physics can be weird, and this undoubtedly the case with quantum mechanics constructed by physicists. 

How can that be? How come that the theory of quantum mechanics is weird, while the atom physics it is supposed to describe cannot be weird? 

We are led to the troubling question: Has quantum mechanics deliberately been constructed by physicists so as to be so weird that it cannot be understood?  

This connects to Newton's admittance that his Principia Mathematica was written to be almost impossible to read (using geometry instead Leibniz Calculus), in order to make criticism from "little smatterers" impossible. Is this the attitude of also modern physicists? 

In any case, if you follow the broad road of weird physics, there is no limit to what weirdness you are allowed to invent, and this now showing up as the crisis of modern physics, witnessed by so many.  

As an antidote to weirdness please take a look at Real Quantum Mechanics and play with its models in Leibniz World of Mathematics Model Workshop 22 Atom Physics. It is very illuminating, in particular to all "little smatterers" like you and me by challenging the ruling dogma of quantum mechanics. Give it a try!

To say that quantum mechanics is weird is a to give up rationality and resort to mysticism. The sad consequence is the present deep crisis in the affairs of the world, caused by irrational thinking of leading human minds, ultimately rooted in weird physics.  If the foundation is weird, everything built thereon is weird.  

PS Of course media is flooded by articles selling the idea that quantum mechanics is weird as a preparation to massive public spending on quantum computing. The more weird theory the more likely it will work in practice.   

fredag 24 september 2021

Kritik av Skolverket i Ny Avhandling om Matematik+Programmering

Peter Vinnervik ger Skolverket svidande kritik i sin avhandling om den nya kursplanen med programmering som del av matematikämnet, vilket tas upp i artikeln Forskare: Skolverket är otydliga om programmering i Läraren:

  • Skolans styrdokument ger inte lärarna tillräckligt bra stöd för hur de ska undervisa i programmering.
  • Man talar om att eleverna ska lära sig programmeringens grunder, men vad de består av kommuniceras väldigt kortfattat i kursplanerna, framför allt för ämnet matematikbudskapet om programmering kommuniceras via flera olika texter. 
  • Man är väldigt otydlig med vad det är för kunskaper som eleverna ska lära sig. 
  • Lärarna upplever budskapet som väldigt luddigt.
  • Det behövs ytterligare en revidering av kursplanerna för att göra det tydligare för lärarna hur de ska arbeta med programmering i undervisningen.
Peter Vinnervik går så långt att han föreslår att programmering skall överföras till teknikämnet, eftersom reform av matematikundervisningen förefaller vara utsiktslös. 

Vi får se om Skolverket kan lyssna på denna kritik. Skolverkets syn uttrycks av undervisningsråd Johan Falk, som i Läraren uttrycker Skolverket: Ge mattelärare tid att fortbilda sig i programmering:
  •  Studiematerial och tillfällen till fortbildning i programmering finns. 
  • Flaskhalsen är tid och den är det bara skolhuvudmännen som kan skapa för sina lärare.
Innebörden är att Skolverket inte anser att Skolverket kan göra något mer än det som redan gjorts. 

Det skall bli intressant att se om Skolverket är kapabelt att lyssna på något av den svidande kritiken från Vinnervik. Det är inte säkert. Som Skolverkets Generaldirektör Peter Fredriksson urskuldande brukar säga: "Matematik är inte Sveriges bästa gren".

From Vinnervik's Abstract:

The results show that teachers face several intrinsic and extrinsic challenges during the process of integrating programming in their teaching. A perceived lack of professional knowledge and understanding of programming among the teachers emerged as a prominent challenge both prior to and more than two years into the reform. Additional challenges are related to teaching materials, time for preparation and professional development. In technology education, teachers mainly see programming as a medium to explore and understand technological systems and construction work. They are uncertain of what programming means in terms of practices and concepts, and about learning progression and assessment. The results further reveal that the curriculum texts are sparse on details about what programming knowledge entails. Important strategic decisions are left entirely to the teachers without any clear guidance. In addition, the results indicate that many technology teachers work in isolation and that interdisciplinary work around programming, as intended in the curriculum, is generally lacking. It is concluded that there is a risk of inequality among schools and that the children’s experience of programming becomes fragmented, despite good intentions. The current implementation model needs to be improved, and this thesis presents two possible actions.


måndag 20 september 2021

New Math Education Site: Leibniz World of Math

I have changed the name of my mathematics education project to Leibniz World of Math from the previous DigiMat Encyclopedia. Take a look!