torsdag 20 september 2012

Strindberg om Skapelsens Matematik


Den Bortglömde August Strindberg grävs förtjänstfullt fram i dagens Svd i en intressant artikel av författare Bo Gustavsson, som nära kopplar till The World as Computation:
  • De centrala texterna i ”Ordalek och småkonst” är de båda tankedikterna ”Rosa mystica” och ”Skapelsens tal och lagar”. 
  • De representerar en höjdpunkt i Strindbergs lyriska författarskap. 
  • Det är märkliga texter där han förenar matematik och mystik, naturvetenskap och spekulativ filosofi. 
  • Grundidén är att universum styrs av matematiska lagar, vilket ju även utgör premissen för modern vetenskap. 
  • Strindberg skulle kunna instämma i Einsteins uttalande att Gud inte kastar tärning.
  • Slumpen existerar inte i vårt ordnade kosmos utan där gäller matematiska talförhållanden både på mikro- och makronivå.
  • "Skapelsens tal och lagar" inleds med ett citat ur Leibniz ”Teodicé”: 
  • Calculat Deus et mundus fit (Gud planerar och världen skapas). 
  • Inspirerad av pythagoreiska tankegångar gör Strindberg Skaparen till en matematiker och geometriker som likt kabbalans Gud tänker universums grundstruktur:
Calculat Deus et mundus fit!; det är
uttolkat: Varde!
Varde med tal och med mått; så börjar
Skapelseverket.
Punkten är vila; den rör sig framåt, och
linjen är skapad.
Linjen s’en med sig själv den alstrar en
täckande yta.
Ytorna avla, och straxt den rummet
fyllande kroppen
Blivit en verklighet, försedd med tyngd och
med dragning.
Kropparne draga varann, de större de
draga de smärre;
Detta är kraft, den dragande kraft, som rör
Universum.
Kärleken kallas den ock, som håller Alltet
tillsammans;
Hatet det stöter ifrån; det söndrar, löser och
dödar. –
Rörelse alltså i tal och i skönmått är början
till livet.
  • Här anspelas på Newtons gravitationslag och Empedokles idé att två krafter styr tillvaron: kärleken och hatet. 
  • Det är en mäktig upptakt till en modern lärodikt. Utifrån ”Zohar”, kabbalans urkund, låter Strindberg talmystik bli ordningsprincipen i universum. Ett är Skaparens tal, oföränderligt och evigt detsamma. 
  • Två är fördelningens tal och tre är familjens, statens och rikenas tal. Sedan för han ett intrikat resonemang om matematiska relationer mellan avstånden från planeterna till solen i ”sfärernas harmoni”. 
  • Även materien styrs av talförhållanden och en ömsesidig dragningskraft mellan grundämnena som Strindberg i alkemisk anda uppfattar som erotisk-mystisk.
Läs och begrunda. Notera särskilt att statistik och tärningskast inte ingår i Skapelsen.


onsdag 19 september 2012

Computation Connects Theory and Practice of Fluid Dynamics


The virtual computational wind tunnel bridges the gap between theory and practice of fluid dynamics.

The Epilogue of The Dawn of Fluid Dynamics, commented on in the preceding post, discusses the relation between science and technology, or between theory and practice, with focus on the development of fluid dynamics during the 20th century as the privileged science during two World Wars and Prandtl as the Father of Modern Fluid Mechanics:
  • Fluid dynamics benefited from the high expectations with which patrons in government and philanthropic foundations, at the armed forces and in the industry, regarded this science.
  • The community of international fluid dynamicists was a mix of practical engineers and academic scientists whose institutional affiliation varied from applied mathematics to mechanical engineering...regarding Prandtl as the founding father of their discipline. G. I- Taylor addressed him as "our chief" who deserved a Nobel Prize.
  • Prandtl confessed to a preference to this approach (practice rather than theory): "When faced with problems in mechanics, I slowly became a accustomed to "see" forces and accelerations in the equations or to "sense" then by tactile feeling.
  • In this book, we have described to what extent the gap between theory and practice was bridged in the age of Prandtl. Surprisingly, physics showed little interest in fluid dynamics.
The gap between theory and practice in fluid dynamics opened already at the start with d'Alembert's paradox and did not diminish under the influence from Prandtl but only got deeper. 

However, when it is now possible, as we show, to computationally solve the Navier-Stokes equations in direct simulation thus offering a virtual wind tunnel, theory and practice comes together for the first time. In particular the Secret of Flight can be revealed.    


tisdag 18 september 2012

The Dusk of Fluid Dynamics


The Dawn of Fluid Mechanics by Michael Eckert (2006) is presented as follows:
  • This is the first publication to describe the evolution of fluid dynamics as a major field in modern science and engineering. It contains a description of the interaction between applied research and application, taking as its example the history of fluid mechanics in the 20th century.
  • The focus lies on the work of Ludwig Prandtl, founder of the aerodynamic research center (AVA) in Göttingen, whose ideas and publications have influenced modern aerodynamics and fluid mechanics in many fields. While suitable for others, this book is intended for natural scientists and engineers as well as historians of science and technology.
The book gives valuable information on Prandtl, his role as German scientist through two World Wars, and his role as Father of Modern Fluid Mechanics. We cite from Chapter 8 Prandtl, Fluid Dynamics and National Socialism:
  • The question how fluid dynamics fared under the new regime cannot be answered without closer inspection of Prandtl's own political attitude. Such inspection brings to the fore a most ambivalent relationship between science and politics. 
  • In November 1933, Prandtl expressed in a private letter to his brother-in-law his satisfaction that one can now "as a German carry the head higher again". 
  • Prandtl was more than willing to place his capabilities and his institute to regime's disposal and the regime appreciated and honored Prandtl for this service.
  • In contrast to physics and mathematics, which experience a decline as a result of Nazi politics, fluid dynamics flourished in the Third Reich.
  • The regime's interest in aerodynamics research soon manifested itself in terns of generous financial support. Aeronautical research experienced a boom which was believed to be impossible before 1933.
  • Göring declared to the congregated scientists in an address at a meeting of the German  Academy of Aeronautical Research "Fluid dynamics has to combine with Air Force research in order to clear the basic laws form application to the Air Force and to guide the development align new paths".
  • Göring and his ministry also made use of Prandtl's reputation for propaganda purposes...to portray Nazi Germany as a country where science was still in high esteem, despite the purge of Jewish scientists from the universities. There are no indications that Prandtl felt uncomfortable with this role...he informed Göring in a letter in December 1936 of the measures that will be taken in his institute "for the conversion of research at a beginning of war".
  • Prandtl, like many other strongly nationally minded Germans, was impressed by the Nazi's determination to free Germany from what they considered the manacle of the Versailles treaty.
  • Göring praised German aeronautical research although "the collapse of our empire after the end of the war has prevented this good tradition from being continued". Only "the resolution of our Fuhrer to restore for Germany the military authority robbed by the Versailles dictate" made it possible to follow this tradition once again. At such occasions, Prandtl often sat in the front row next to the highest authorities of the Nazi regime.
  • When the German Academy of Aeronautical Research met on March 1 1939, Prandtl was awarded in the presence of numerous foreign celebrities the "Hermann Göring medal", the Nazi's highest distinction for scientific merit in aeronautics.
  • In May 1937 Prandtl wrote to William Knight the former NACA representative in Paris "I believe that Fascism in Italy and National Socialism in Germany represent very good beginnings of new thinking and economics".  
  • Prandtl described Hitler as a "man of tremendous nerve" who admittedly "made himself a million people his bitter enemies, but on the other side eighty million people his faithful and ardent followers".
  • With regard to the "Jewish question" he argued "The struggle which Germany unfortunately had to fight against the Jews, was necessary for its self-preservation".
  • Prandtl was neither naive nor forced against his will to participate in "the propaganda mission" as he called his efforts to sell Hitler's plans for a new order to the scientific world.
One should maybe bear these sides of Prandtl's soul in mind when recognizing him as the Father of Modern Fluid Mechanics. Prandtl as scientist is further scrutinized in Dr Faustus of Modern Physics. 

Request for Re-Evaluation by AIAA of New Theory of Flight

A request has been sent to AIAA Journal Editor-in-Chief for a re-evaluation of the submitted article New Theory of Flight, which was rejected by an associate editor.  The reason put forward is that the new elements of the article were not subject to evaluation in an AIAA review process with the main objective of defending exactly the Old Theory questioned by the article.

The review process including referee reports and editors comments will be subject to an analysis in the spirit of Thomas Kuhn in the upcoming book The Secret of Flight.

Kutta-Zhukovsky-Prandtl Devoid of Physics

David Auerbach starts out in Why Aircraft Fly by:
  • The question as to the origin of lift is older than Newton who, himself, gave the wrong answer (see, for example, Toakaty [1]). The vortex theory of flight due to Zhukowsky [2], Kutta [3], Lanchester [4] and Prandtl [5], although doubted by few, appears to many so devoid of any direct experiential basis that there are constant attempts to understand why an aircraft really manages to remain aloft: the idea of a bound vortex with its circulation seems so passive, the explanation, so abstruse and complicated.
Read and contemplate! These are tough words about the Old Theory of Flight of Kutta-Zhukovsky-Prandtl. Are they true?

Hyperphysics: Bernoulli of Newton's Law for Lift?

The explanation of the generation of lift of a wing on the educational site Hyperphysics gives evidence of the depth of the crisis of present aerodynamics education:
  • Which is best for describing how aircraft get the needed lift to fly? Bernoulli's equation or Newton's laws and conservation of momentum? 
  • This has been an extremely active debate among those who love flying and are involved in the field. 
  • If the question is "Which is physically correct?" then the answer is clear -- both are correct. 
  • Both are based on valid principles of physics. The Bernoulli equation is simply a statement of the principle of conservation of energy in fluids. Conservation of momentum and Newton's 3rd law are equally valid as foundation principles of nature - we do not see them violated. 
  • This physical validity will undoubtedly not quell the debate, and this treatment will not settle it. But perhaps it can at least indicate the lines of the discussion.
We see two explanations of the generation of lift being presented, both expressing valid physics, but both being trivial as being self-evident: lift by lower pressure above (Bernoulli) or lift as reaction (Newton). This is true but carries no interesting information like any triviality.

Each proponent of an explanation can rightly accuse the other for presenting a triviality and so the proponents cannot meet, although they share equally valid trivial arguments.


Airbus: Free-Glide Approaches and Landing



Airbus presents on its web site as a Smarter Skies vision to use Free-Glide Approaches and Landing:

  • Allowing aircraft to take free glide approaches into airports would lower emissions during the overall decent and reduce noise during the steeper approach as there is no need for engine thrust or air breaking.
  • These approaches also would reduce the landing speed earlier, making shorter landing distances achievable with less runway needed.
To come up with designs allowing free-glide with reduced landing speeds, accurate computational simulation of the full aircraft at large angles of attack would be very useful. 

The open source FEniCS/Unicorn Navier-Stokes/slip solver for slightly viscous incompressible flow, seems to have the capability for such a task.

The Princeton Sailwing





















Double-cloth sailwing supported by trailing edge cable with lift an drag coefficients right.

From A Comparison of the Aerodynamic Characteristics of Eight Sailwing Airfoil Sections by M. Maughmer (1979):
  • The Princeton sailwing, which has been under development since 1948, is a unique, semiflexible wing intended to provide the practical ultimate in a light-weight, low-cost lifting surface suitable for a number of low- speed applications. 
  • Basically, the structural configuration of the sailwing consists of a leading-edge spar with attached ribs which ideally form a rigid framework supporting a trailing-edge cable in tension. 
  • A non-porous, non-stretchable cloth membrane, usually dacron, is then wrapped around the leading-edge and attached to the trailing-edge forming the upper and lower sail surfaces....it has been found that the aerodynamic efficiency of the sailwing can indeed approach that of a hard wing.
Compare with Chapter 5 From Circular Cylinder to Wing in The Secret of Flight.

Note that with a single cloth membrane, like an ordinary sail, the lift-to-drag ratio decreases from about 15 to 10 because of the effect of a one-sided leading edge (mast) to increase drag and decrease lift.  

måndag 17 september 2012

How to Answer a Question You Cannot Answer


The question how a wing generates lift gets the following answer on Wikipedia under Lift Force:
  • There are several ways to explain how an airfoil generates lift. Some are more complicated or more mathematically rigorous than others; some have been shown to be incorrect.
  • Most of them are intended to explain the phenomenon of lift to a general audience. Several theories introduce assumptions which proved to be wrong, like the equal transit-time theory.
The idea, used by many agencies expected to have an answer like NASA or AIAA, is to say that the answer to be presented is suitable for a "general audience" and as such it is not the correct answer, while suggesting that there is a correct answer certainly known to the agency, but that this correct answer is not suitable for presentation to a "general audience". 

This is believed to be a very smart way of covering up that the agency does not really know any correct answer: Give an incorrect answer (and there are many to choose from) and claim that for sure there is a correct answer, which however is not suitable for the general audience. 

You can study this very clever and effective tactics in the preceding sequence of posts on Incorrect or Empty Flight Theory. Have fun.

PS1 One may compare with different answers to the question from where babies come, which can vary depending on the audience. The question has to be answered, in one way or the other, because it is a very good question, and even an incorrect answer is then an answer, but it is not science.

PS2 As an real-life illustration study my Interview with Glenn Research Center:
  • The correct theory of lift is fairly complex. saying that the answer is complex means just that ... it is complex, it isn't simple. But we know what it is.
  • Many people look for simple answers to questions, when the answer may not be simple. When the answer is really complex, people make simplifying assumptions so that they can get a simple answer. Unfortunately, with fluid mechanics, when you make simplifying assumptions you can get the wrong answer. That's what has happened with the incorrect theories and their inability to produce meaningful results.

Empty Flight Theory at Boeing

Boeing presents as a service to the community the following information on Forces of Flight/Lift/Basics:
  • Lift is the upward force that counteracts gravity and enables airplanes to fly.
  • Lift keeps birds, gliders, and airplanes aloft as they move forward through the air. Lift is also generated by the spinning blades of a helicopter.
  • Aerodynamic lift is based on Daniel Bernoulli’s Principle, which states that the pressure of a flowing fluid or gas decreases as its velocity increases. To take advantage of this, an airplane wing, like a bird wing, is designed with a distinctive shape called an airfoil. This shape creates the greatest possible lift for the airplane.
  • The shape of an airplane wing, the angle at which the wing meets the airflow, and the speed of the airplane all affect the lift.
This information is preceded by a friendly: 
  • Welcome to "Forces of Flight," a new Boeing program created to help classroom teachers to excite and engage students about science.
  • We hope that you will find this program helpful and interesting. 
  • We are proud to partner with teachers who are making the effort to inspire the next generation of scientists.
  • In addition to being informative, this program is intended to promote student inquiry by linking the information on the posters and web site to a series of classic hands-on physics experiments that demonstrate how the forces of flight actually work.
But what Boeing offers to young minds eager to understand why it is possible to fly, is not a correct explanation of the generation of lift, in fact no explanation at all: It is only a vague hint that somehow it is the shape of a wing that generates lift, which is directly contradicted by suggesting that it is maybe instead the angle of attack that gives (a symmetric wing) lift. 

None of the natural questions from the students can be answered this way which can only teach that science is a hopeless mess which cannot excite and engage students. 

The question then presents itself: Does Boeing know how a wing generates lift?

To check out I sent today the following mail to Boeing:
  • On the web site The Secret of Flight I present a New Theory of Flight (submitted to AIAA) giving a new explanation of the generation of lift and drag of a wing, which is fundamentally different from classical text-book theory.
  • My question: How does Boeing explain the generation of lift of a wing? 
I will report the answer. Here it is:

Thank you for your message to the Boeing Web feedback box. The best source of information on The Boeing Company and our products is our public website: www.boeing.com

You can find a great deal of information using the search tool. Try clicking on the “About Us” link, which will take you to pages on history and research assistance (including an aviation reading list and related aerospace sites).

Due to the high volume of requests we receive, we cannot provide any additional information or research assistance than what can be found on our public website.

Thank you for your interest in Boeing.

Kind regards,
Boeing Webmaster